Very difficult Lullaby Paint (white, semi gloss) was extremely difficult to paint with. It was gloppy, thick, and quite streaky. I would not buy it again.

Decent primer/paint for what we needed We ordered primer and paint (in a custom color) for our baby's crib. We were excited to find something baby and pregnancy safe, so we took the plunge and ordered. We did a custom color, and that turned out great - perfect match, as far as we can tell! Shipment arrived on time and in perfect condition. The paint was so-so as far as application. We typically use a pretty good quality Sherwin-Williams paint when we have projects, so that is the quality we're used to, and it certainly was not on par with that. Paint had to be applied very thin, or we got terrible marks in it. We did two coats, and overall I think it looks good. We got the semi gloss, and it's not glossy at all. In hindsight, I would have opted for a gloss finish for furniture instead.

Glad it's safe could offer better coverage. We wanted to paint a baby crib. The shipment was fast and came in great packaging. It's of course a bit pricey. The color was wonderful and exactly as represented on the website. I found the paint to be a bit watery and drip marks became a problem while painting. After three coats it looked nice though. Other paints offer a much better product (with better coverage) but safety was my number one concern so I see it as worth the cost, watery consistency, and extra coat of paint.

Frustrated The paint I received was not anywhere close to the paint I chose. I tried to call and speak to someone, left a message, and never got a call back. They do not exchange paint, even if unopened, and when they are at fault. The shipping cost almost as much as the paint. I will not order from them again.

Crib Revamp Overall I was very happy with my Lullaby Paint purchase. The color is beautiful. However, the paint is very thin (due to how safe it is I'm sure) so the lighter colors do not cover well and I really could have used another quart (despite what was recommended by the site). Even after using the Lullaby Paint Primer I still had a lot of issues with the original crib color coming through.